Smucker’s Organic Creamy Peanut Butter, 16 oz Jar

This peanut butter tastes as good as Jif, which I ate for years and wouldn’t settle for anything else. But when I found out I was prediabetic, I switched to Smuckers Organic Peanut Butter. The only downside is that it must be stirred, but a good initial stirring is all that’s required. Helpful hint, store it upside down before stirring. Makes a world of difference!

Smucker’s Organic Creamy Peanut Butter delivers a clean, authentic peanut flavor that truly stands out. The texture is rich and velvety, spreading effortlessly whether you’re making a quick sandwich or adding it to a recipe. I appreciate the simple, organic ingredients—no unnecessary additives—just pure, wholesome goodness. The natural oil separation is a sign of quality, and with a quick stir, it blends perfectly into a smooth consistency. The taste is fresh, slightly roasted, and not overly sweet, making it a versatile pantry staple. Packaged in a sturdy glass jar, it also feels premium. Overall, this is a reliable, high-quality peanut butter that elevates everyday meals.

Get a load of this natural peanut butter with a nice consistency that is not soupy and will not run off your sandwich! I still dump the oil off and stir this one. But am so sick of buying natural brands of soupy peanut butters. Even after dumping the oil off, stirring, the peanut butter is still runny. I've tried lots and have ended up sticking to this Organic Natural one. The Natural one that's not organic is soupy but this one is not. Weird, huh? Especially when being made by the same company. Oh well, pay the extra and get a non-runny peanut butter like this!

Our family LOVES peanuts--ALL peanuts including in-shell. Our preference is ORGANIC but, while it's extremely rare to get organic peanuts in-shell, we thoroughly enjoy the organic peanut butter! It's great on toasted breads, crackers, bananas, and straight [on a spoon]! Smucker's is our favorite brand of all.

This is delicious peanut butter without unnecessary ingredients. Some of the natural oils from the peanuts do separate. Thus, the peanut butter has to be stirred when you first open the jar. Rather than buying the large jar, I prefer to get two small jars (16 oz) because the smaller jars are so much easier and quicker to stir.

I like how it has a little grit to it. Not super smooth but I like it like this. Best flavor too. I buy it because it's in a glass jar and it's organic. THANK YOU!

My favorite since giving up added sugar products! Only contains peanuts and salt. It isn't completely smooth; it does contain tiny bits of peanuts. And like with any natural peanut butter, it will separate. I remix with one beater in my electric hand mixer and a VERY FIRM grip on the jar. Good stuff!

Excellent taste and not full of sugar. Once the oil has been mixed in we leave it on the counter with no problems. Unfortunately it has not been on the shelf lately at Walmart in East Syracuse so I was forced to place an order online. I hope they bring it back. Best peanut butter we have ever tasted and this is our go-to brand!

Texture it's somewhere between Batter and peanut butter. it has lots of little bits of peanuts in it , which actually is horrible.. crunchy has bigger pieces in it this they're smaller than a pea The flavor is also off. not foul. just not peanut like enough . Unless you like tiny little bits of things in your peanut butter , I do not recommend this.

I accepted this recommendation as a substitute. I’m disappointed. It doesn’t smell like peanut butter. The taste isn’t good. The texture is weird, with small dark specks. I used it in a sweet-treat recipe and it turned out strange and mushy. I would never buy it again, and certainly do not recommend. Too, the price is way higher than comparable brands.