Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eye Liner Micro Tip - Shimmering Garnet , 0.016 oz Eyeliner

This is the most precise eyeliner I've ever used. Like all Stila All Day Waterproof liners, it is truly long-lasting and resistant to smudging.I love the brush tip (pencils don't work for me at all). I tried a variety of cheaper liquid eyeliners and found that they just didn't work nearly as well.

I'm sorry the previous reviewer had such a bad experience! I'm actually writing this review so others don't get discouraged- I'm not much for writing reviews but I really love this eyeliner. I used to go back and forth between the standard size Stila pen eyeliner and Kat Von D's pen, but the Stila always had better staying power. Sometimes I would get frustrated though, as I prefer a very fine line. I have a fair complexion and blonde hair, so too much black eyeliner can be pretty harsh. I do like a small amount very close to my lashes. This works perfectly! I've had mine since it came out and have had no problems at all. I'm thinking there was a bad batch maybe and the previous reviewer unfortunately got some of those. I'm not a paid reviewer and don't work for Stila or anything weird - I just don't want people to stay away based on 1 review.

This is perfect for my very hooded eyes. This gives me the perfect thin liner and perfect wing. I try to use other liners but keep going back to this one. Hands down my favorite liner.

I was super excited to try the still out as I was searching for a fine tip to apply the most delicate of cat eyes that reach into the inner corner of my eye. While I absolutely love how the liner handles, the intense black color, and the smooth application, my liner is in no way waterproof, smearproof, or tear-proof. I have hooded eyes and so when I look down and/or blink my eyeliner will top the top of my crease line, which now has a smear of grey. Also, I have sensitive eyes to the cold which causes them to often tear up when the wind hits them. Today it was not even bitter cold (27) and I was left with an elongated smear on the inner corner and the cat-eye trail of my eye. It is frustrating to me as I was heading into the office for an interview rather than my stay-at-home normal lifestyle where this wouldn't have occurred. In all, I am very disappointed that their -proof claim was not able to hold up to its claims. Purchased at Ulta beauty in Monroeville, PA

I finally purchased this product after I heard so much about how great the formula is, that it's long-wearing and very easy to draw with. I've exchanged the product twice now (through Ulta) and each time the tip is completely dry. At first I thought, okay, I'll just need to shake it to get the product flowing. Nope...it's been 30 minutes of shaking every which way and nothing has come out. One of the ones I purchased I actually managed to get some of the product out but it was only enough to do one eye. I was hoping this was just a QC problem but it seems like it's more of an issue with the product itself. Would not recommend.

The smaller felt tip makes it easy to create a nice fine line. Good staying power, too. The shimmer imparts a bit of understated glam as well.

I love how thin this line is. Great for bottom lashes. Doesn't wear off or run during my 12 hour shifts.

After trying a variety of cheaper liquid eyeliners, I came back to Stila. It's the easiest to use and the most long-lasting. I'm happy that Stila offers the Alloy (gray) color, which suits my gray hair and is softer-looking than black.

I used the tester on my hand and it was perfect. Exactly what id expect. Bring it home . How the tester is better than the actual product I don't know. The tip was so dry . Nothing went on my eye. What so ever. And I have at least 20 lines on my hand all faded. Returning it as we speak. So brutal.

It really must've been an issue with Ulta because this liner is great! Really precise and true black. I'll definitely be coming back for more. I like it better than Tarte's, and most that I've tried. Long-lasting and precise as it says. A must have!!!