I had a cake decorating kit from 1988. So, I'm comparing these to them. I was missing a few tips and needed a stand. This was a cheap kit, so I bought it. The tips weren't the quality of the 1988 ones. (ONLY reason for the four star/not five) But, I think they will do the job. Unlike my older ones that are solid, these have a seam on the side and seem lighter weight. But, for a starter kit it would be a great gift. Everything needed to get started! I haven't got to use them yet. But, I think they will be fine.