This was a replacement for wore out. This is a great, warm jacket for taking the dog out and getting wood. I love that the neck collar goes up higher than a regular jacket. The most important things for me was quality, fit, and price. this jacket checks all those boxes. I ordered a size larger because I wear thicker clothing in the winter-even though I'm female. If I were going to be super picky, I wish the cuffs had an an elastic band so the wind didnt blow up the sleeves on those really cold, windy days. I've been looking for an affordable one for literally years. I'm glad I found this one.