(3 pack) Great Value Organic Creamy Stir Peanut Butter, 16 oz

Its organic which is my main concern. It is a bit runny. I pour off the extra oil from the top before stirring. Tastes fine and the price is great. With tariffs messing up our entire economy, I try to save where I can and this helps. I'm big on crackers and PB for a quick snack.

I highly recommend this peanut butter. I do have to take it out of the jar and stir it because of the oil separation but it is only done once. The taste is delicious and this peanut butter has no additives like, sugar. This is the healthiest peanut butter you can get just peanuts and salt. I wouldn't eat anything else.

I've become health conscious of late and I read some articles on the Internet saying that organic peanut butter was much better for your health than non organic offerings So I tried the great value organic peanut butter for the first time and the taste was good but the only thing I take away from it, is the fact that it was too runny. My experience with organic peanut butters in the past has shown that the oil from the peanut butter normally separates from it and you have to kind of mix it all back together again to get a good consistency. But this jar that I had recently bought was far too runny even after mixing it back up. It would drip off the spoon or the knife that I was using to spread it on crackers and bread. It was rather disappointing.

This peanut butter is delicious!! My only complaint and it is a big deal is, it is in a plastic container. I was surprised by this because the picture definitely looks like it is in a glass bottle. Please know that people who order organic and unsweetened are also very concerned about consuming bpa plastic solids. I hope you change it because the peanutbutter itself is worthy of 5 stars.

It was good before they put it in plastic jars. There were at least three inches of oil on the top and the peanut butter was liquid even after I stirred it. It was disgusting. The picture of it on line shows it in the regular glass. I wouldn't have bought if I knew they changed it. Gross.

This peanut butter was great, but it recently changed and it's so GROSS now. It's too bitter. It looks different in the jars - it was lighter before and now it's darker. I can't hardly eat it, which is sad because it was so good before. I'll be buying my organic peanut butter elsewhere now.

Taste good…do not like the switch from glass to the flimsy plastic, and it has gotten too thin and runny. It says there is no added oil, but somewhere in the process, possibly with almond roasting?, oil has to have been added. Refrigeration helps, but not enough. Anyway, I don’t like liquid peanut butter. I’ll pay the price difference and go back to Smuckers.

I search out products which are housed in glass containers whenever possible. They changed to plastic jars, so I'll buy the more expensive peanut butter 🥜 instead, next time. Microplastics leach into your food, even more so, when it's an oil based product.

I specifically ordered this because it looked like a glass jar with a metal lid. I was expecting a glass jar with a metal lid but I got a plastic jar with a plastic white lid. Not at all like pictured. The peanut butter itself is great so, if you don't mind the plastic, then go for it.

Bought this brand for the price thinking it was cheaper than the other 2 ingredient organic option that came in a glass jar since that is what the picture shows when ordering online. Nowhere in the description does it state it comes in a plastic container. Then on top of that it is like soup. No way can I use this for my son’s sack lunch needed for his field trip. Beyond disappointing.