(3 pack) NYX Professional Makeup Epic Wear Liner Sticks, Long-Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil, Brown Shimmer, 1 Count

This pencil is real smooth and has a decent pigment. I loveeee it!

It goes on smoothly, is well pigmented and stays. I get the fierce purple and it's a nice, dark purple.

The Chill Blue is my favorite color. Soft, shimmery light blue is gorgeous. Many other great colors that go on easily and last all day. Perfect every day or special eye pencils.

I'm sure it's already discontinued because I can't find it in any stores. But it is such a great color and looks "shockingly" neutral on me. I love it so much

This eyeliner is a great color for brown eyes! I use it on my tight line and have little to no transfer to my lower lash line which is great. My only critique is that I wish the liner was a retractable eyeliner instead of a pencil.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I ordered three of these pencils in blues and teals for a bride who wanted a bold under eye liner. These pencils were exactly what we needed. Full pigment and didn't budge! I will definitely be ordering more in the future.

New to makeup. The actual eyeliner is great. It goes on super thick, super dark, and extremely waterproof, which is great. But the product does not sharpen well at all. I nearly sharpened mine down to half it's standard length before getting lucky and getting a point back on it. I even tried opening the back cap and using a rod to force the eyeliner through the tip like a twist-pencil. Overall, it's a great product, but it's design needs some serious refinement before I can wholeheartedly recommend this to anyone.

Love NYX products I've tried so I thought this would be a winner as well. It's not for me. Does not apply evenly to waterline. Looked very heavy after giving up. Works decent for a brow filler. Was satisfied to use it as that.. but while using, I put the cap on the end to secure while using. When I removed the cap, it pulled the plastic end piece off. Now that is stuck in my lid, can't get it out, therefore can't cover my pencil. Super disappointing. 51yr W/Female

The nude shade—GORGEOUS! Once the liner wears down it's done. Other reviewers have said you can “sharpen” the pencil. How can you sharpen this stick with a finite amount of product to insert into a sharpener. There isn't enough product to sharpen and the barrel is plastic. Do you shave off the plastic as you sharpen the eye liner? 1 star for an amazing color and 1 star for the texture. A twisting barrel to push up the product would be a better option.

I bought this approximately a week ago and wore it twice on my lower water line (I removed it before the picture but it's there to illustrate the irritation it brought on). Severe irritation occured both times within 10 minutes of application. Eyes got red, itchy, felt dry like sand had gotten in them, got watery but couldn't produce tears, vision got blurry, the colour actually bled from my waterline into my eyes and created a grey film on them (I bought the 'pitch black' shade. Super disappointed especially as I use the eyeshadow palettes from this brand all the time with no reaction and have only good things to say about them. This eyeliner needs more work though, maybe some retesting or an adjustment to the formula composition