e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner, Coffee, 0.006 oz

Perfect eyeliner for older women. Works great to put on the edge of your eyelid if it glides on without clumping. Stays unwell throughout the day and provides a glamorous look without being overpowering.

Great price for a quality product. ELF products are now my go to. The eyeliners come in a variety of colors. They are easy to apply and do not smudge. Typically I purchase black and brown. Recently, I tried the charcoal. I recommend it too. Nice subtle change.

I can not say enough good about this eyeliner! E.l.f. is a bargain brand, but this no-budge eyeliner is the BEST i've EVER used! I am an older woman with sensitive skin, so I have to be careful what I use. Not only is this non-irritating, but they are not kidding about the NO BUDGE claim! This is my eyeliner from here on out!

I have very oily and hooded eyelids. Most pencil eyeliners end up smearing and looking messy by the end of the day. Liquid eyeliner precision is too difficult for me to apply these days. This elf pencil liner is very pigmented and stays put for much, much longer than all others I've used. It's not absolutely perfect by the end of the day however I think it would be for those who do not have as oily and hooded eyes as me. Overall, it's very good and close to the Thrive brand which costs 5x more. I recommend you give it a try.

This eyeliner is amazing! With my previous liner, I was always wiping the corners of my eyes because it would melt a bit. I bought this before a long trip because I wanted to apply my make up in the mornings of our tour and not have to worry about it and it delivered! My make up was intact at the end of the day, that made me so happy!

This eye liner goes on easy and does not smudge easily. I like the dark brown color for everyday wear. It's easy to remove with micellar water.

I like how it glides on smoothly,price was not to bad either.Works well so far

This brown eyeliner doesn't apply as smoothly as the same eyeliner in black. I don't understand why that is, but it is frustrating. It takes more time and force to apply since it isn't slick and smooth with application. The color is nice, but the eyeliner fades well before the end of the day and begins to smear a bit too. The black version of this same eyeliner is great! Not sure why this one is so different.

Came in pieces, a very small amount. Not worth the money!

Smudges and transfers very easily to my lower eyelid. Color also disappears over time (photo showing after 2 hours of wear)