Hard Candy Party Lines Felt Tip Liner, Liquid Eyeliner, Waterproof, Little Black Dress, Black

It worked the first time I used it but after that completely dried out. I would not recommend this product. There's similar products that work better for the same price, if not cheaper.

It stays put but it started to dry out quickly, making it hard to use.

This used to be one of the best eyeliners out there - it actually was better than some much more expensive brands I've tried. I'd put this on in the morning and it would still be there at the end of the day. They seemed to repackage it change the formula a while ago and repackage it and since then it's been ok-ish and the lasting power of the eyeliner pen is pretty wimpy - you'll get a stunning black line for a week or so and you'll go to use it and end up with the brush making a kind of sad grey smudge. The waterproof version is slightly better but I found the formula irritating and the brush was quite tiny. Please bring back the old version!!!!

product is very dry and very much more of a translucent gray in the picture the gray on my hand is the hard candy eye liner and the black is eyeliner from the Dollar tree

not as good as I thought it would be

it went on slightly tinted but mostly clear.

i got black waterproof it looks grey or lighter u can berely see it it dosent stay takes off easily..i did not like it at all.

This is awful compared the he original version. It's less pigmented and is basically a grey eyeliner.

Very bad products was dry and didn't even work wanted to return it but I ordered it through the app and it's to much work to return don't recommend

i was given this as a substitute for what i ordered..very allergic!