L'Oreal Paris Double Extend Tubing Mascara Lengthening in 2 Steps, Blackest Black

This has been my holy grail mascara for the past 10 years. I love that it doesn't smudge or flake like traditional mascara. It's impossible to get racoon eyes with this mascara. When removing, it comes off with just water in clumps instead of dissolving. This quality also prevents it from running if you happen to cry or go swimming. If you've never tried a tubing mascara before, I recommend giving it a chance. It's been a game changer for me.

My eyelashes started leaning sideways and would not stand up like they should even with mascara. I tried many things and nothing was working. I called Lo'real and the associate recommended trying tubing mascara. I did and I am very happy to finally have something that will make my lashes look better. I don't wear mascara every day but when I do I can at least look nice. It really does help if your lashes are not looking like they did when you were younger.

I love this product. It is tried and true and continues to provide quality. I have very short thin lashes and the double extend tubing creates a long lash that is not too think, never clumpy. It creates a clean classic look. Requires use of an eyelash curler, and does not smear. It stays on until I wash it off.

I have oily lids and watery eyes, so mascara usually becomes my nightmare 2 hours in. I was researching, and tubing mascara popped up. I've worn it for hours with no burning, no smudging or smearing, and zero “raccoon eyes” from bleeding. Highly recommend!

This mascara is absolutely fabulous! There are other brands of tubing mascara sold only online that are more than twice the price. This is not only affordable, but it also lasts all day and is so easy to remove with warm water. It doesn't smear or flake off. This will always be my favorite mascara.

My Lashes Finally Met Their Match (And It's Not My Phone Camera) I've tried more mascaras than I care to admit—waterproof ones that require a hazmat suit to remove, volumizing ones that leave me with spider legs, and "lengthening" ones that do absolutely nothing. This one caught my attention because of the tubing concept, which sounded like science I didn't understand but was willing to try. The two-step process is simple: first, the white primer/base coat goes on and actually adds noticeable length without looking clumpy. Second, the black tubing coat seals everything in. The difference is real—my lashes looked significantly longer, defined, and separated, not like I glued a bunch of fibers on. The real test came at the end of the day. Regular mascara usually leaves me with raccoon eyes by noon. This stuff? It came off in little tubes with just warm water and gentle pressure. No rubbing, no tugging, no lost lashes. It stayed put through humidity, a few tears at a sad movie, and everything else. · What I liked: The length is genuinely impressive—people asked if I was wearing falsies. It doesn't smudge or flake throughout the day. Removal is shockingly easy with just warm water. The primer adds a nice base that makes lashes look fuller. · What I'd note for others: You have to let the white coat dry slightly before applying the black, or it can get a bit tacky. The tubing effect means you can't just rub your eyes—you have to use warm water to dissolve the tubes. It's a two-step process, so it takes an extra minute compared to one-step mascaras. It's become my new go-to for days when I want my lashes to actually look like something. I'm hoping the formula stays consistent and the tubes don't start misbehaving after a few months of use, because this is the first mascara that's made me excited about my lashes in years.

This is the only mascara that I use. Has been for years. I don't want to wear fake eyelashes and with this I don't have to. It thickens and lengthens my lashes without fake lashes. glue and all that comes with using fake. I use the waterproof. It comes off with soap and water.

I have tried dozens and dozens of mascaras and I keep coming back to this one. Tubing mascaras are amazing, but typically are not water/sweat proof. I don't know if it's the base coat (thank you for fixing the gumminess L'Oréal!) but this mascara has lasted through golf tournaments in 90+ degree weather! It is by far one of the best for length and volume and is superior in its water resistance. On my wish list would be a nice warm brown shade, but I'm thrilled with this mascara and it will always be my #1

I really wanted to love this tubing mascara but sadly I don't. I didn't notice any extra volume and length. But the kicker was taking it off. Man, it was difficult to remove. I used micellar water..nothing. I used a make up remover wipe and it came off in clumps, very weird.

This product is garbage. I bought a second tube thinking it must have been a bad batch and nope. It sticks to my skin top and bottom lashes, and over curls so much that the tips of my eyelashes bend backwards like hooks, actually making them look shorter. Have never had this problem with a mascara in the past. Perhaps the curl feature works for some people, I could get over that aspect if it wasn't for the clumping and sticking to my skin part which is the absolute worst. Sticky clumping over curling and gross.