L'Oreal Paris Infallible Pro Last Waterproof Eyeliner, Black, 2 Pack

LOVE IT!!!!!! i’ve used another eye liner for years and wasn’t extremely happy with it so i tried this one and i will never go back!!! i’m absolutely amazed!!!!!! glides on so easy!! sharpens easy and doesn’t smudge! i sleep in my makeup sometimes, don’t judge LOL! but it’s still looks perfect!!! no flaking !! LOVE THIS!!!!!!

I've been using this product for years; always get complimented regardless of what color I use. I also wear the brown and black eyeliners, but the blue is my favorite.

L’Oréal sells a sharpener to use to keep the pencil sharp. They also suggest keeping the pencil in the freezer prior to sharpening. This pencil is the only liner that I have tried that stays on even when my eyes water when outside. It is the best!

Love the bronze color. This is a soft pencil that requires frequent resharpening. There is no smudger at the other end of the pencil. Otherwise I'm very happy with it.

Love the color and formula but you can’t sharpen it which makes it useless - it gets rough and sharp when you sharpen it and ruins the tip

Good for about a week. You cannot sharpen this pencil even with their own brand sharpener - it just crumbles. I tried this item more than once thinking maybe just a fluke but nope. Consistent problem negating how I feel about the product. The cost for such a short lived item is soooo not worth it. Save your money and try something else. I’d like my money back

Do not waste your money on this pencil, super hard to sharpen and does not go on easily. Even when you do sharpen it, it does not sharpen to a point, so if you want precise eyeliner (such as wings) this is not the one to use.

I bought this pencil today and it doesn't glide at all. I thought sharpening it would help but it is still very dry. It tugs and pulls on the skin so I don't know how I am supposed to use on a sensitive area like eyes. I don't know if I got an expired product of what but very disappointed in the product because I bought it after seeing videos of some influencers using it. Now this is a complete waste of money for me. I need a resolution for this.

For the last three purchases product worked good until got about half way down then product stopped working. It seemed waxy, then as I sharpened and got lower it kept breaking off. So only got to use half of each stick. Not worth the price!

While I love the bronze color….the eyeliner itself is a total waste of money. It does not sharpen well and never to a point. It smears everywhere as a result. L'Oréal needs to address this issue of waste.