Maybelline ExpertWear Brow and Eyeliner Pencil, Velvet Black

Wonderful inexpensive eyebrow pencil and liner. Delivery was prompt for a hard to find eye pencil. Works better than the $30 one by another company. Lasts a long time.

This was my favorite eyeliner for years. Then CVS stopped carrying it. I tried others but did not care for them at all. I finally did a Google search and found the product available on just a few websites. Walmart had the best price and appears to have adequate quantities so I can order again in the future. I find this easier to apply, like the color (I use dark brown sometimes, black at other times). Like the look.

I received my pencils less than a week after ordering! I had made many trips to different Walmart's in my area with no luck in finding what I wanted and if I did it was the wrong color! My son was the one who told me to do it online. He works for Sam's Club so I thought why not!? Good Call.

Apparently Maybelline discontinued these brow pencils which I have used for years. Found them on the Walmart site, ordered several and received them in a few days. Thanks, Walmart!

Well, I wear this and then they stopped selling it in the store bringing in new products new items and I thought well look online and see if they might have it cause I have had this particular one for a good while and sure enough when I got online and I had the number, I always kept the Little box after you cut your pen out to make sure I don't ever forget the number and stuff so yes, they had it online. I ordered it and I got it the other day and I'm like so happy to get what I wanted online and that's what I wear and it was the same exact box same exact number and the same exact color thank you for having it and sending it my way.

I've used this pencil for years and then could not find it anywhere. I know that Maybelline had quit making some of their products, yes the ones I have used for years, but finding a decent replacement is impossible. I paid lots of money for other brow pencils that put too much color on and caused your brows to look drawn in. This simple pencil works best. My advice to Maybelline, leave your great, time-proven products alone! Thank Walmart for keeping this in stock.

I've been waiting for this eyebrow pencil to come back and start for years thank you Maybelline

This is the same eyebrow pencil I have used for years and noticed it was no longer carried in the stores. I was glad I could still find it here, however, the product showing in the picture is NOT the product you will receive. There is NO sharpener at the bottom. As I have been using eye brow powder, rather than the pencil, for the past couple of years, I still like to keep it on hand for touch ups. Thankfully, I kept one of my old sharpeners from one of the old pencils. It is a great product and so sad to see it no longer carried in the stores. Just glad it's still cheap online and I was able to get 4 which should last me a good, long time.

The item shown is the original pencil that came with a built in sharpener. The silver line shown is where the sharpener used to be located. None of the pencils I received had the sharpener. I had also ordered these from Amazon since they are no longer available in the drugstores. Those from Amazon also did not have the sharpener shown. Please talk to maybelline to see what's happening.

Best eyeliner ever! Too bad it's discontinued by Maybelline and they haven't replaced it with anything comparable to this product. Hope they reconsider and bring it back.