Maybelline Eye Studio Master Precise Pencil Eyeliner, Coal Commander

When I was younger I used to use the old school red pencil Maybelline eyeliner. Getting older, I've tried different kinds of eyeliners which either smeared, irritated my eyes, wore off, etc. I live in Thailand and shopping for an eyeliner, online especially, is difficult since I cannot sample it. I took a chance and decided to come back to Maybelline and purchased this. It was perfect. The color went on smoothly, didn't smear, and looked fresh throughout the day. This exceeded my expectation. I definitely recommend it.

I've used so many different eyeliners at all price ranges and this eyeliner from Maybelline is by far the best at ease of application and of staying power.

Loved the previous formula and brush tip, used it every day ever since it was released. Purchased the new version a couple of days ago and can't emphasise enough what a let down it is. New tip is a sponge that doesn't allow for the "precise" application of the previous design and horrible formula. I purchased the forest brown colour which I do enjoy the appearance of, however, I'm not sure whether its because of the new sponge tip or a different formula but this does not seem to last nearly as long as the blackest black in the previous version. So disappointed by the loss of what I considered one of my holy grail products :(. Used to always recommend the previous version when asked but definitely wont recommend this one.

I have been buying this eyeliner for many years and have always stayed so loyal to it, but now it's changed to a new terrible design that isn't soft on the eyes and the tip is much larger and harder to create an accurate wing. I feel like I'm drawing with a sharpie on my eyelid with this new design. Why would you fix something that wasn't broken in the first place? now this eyeliner is just like any other cheap, bad quality eyeliner that you can find everywhere.

I have been a long time user of this eyeliner. It WAS my holy grail eyeliner - it beat ALL the top end brands in my opinion. I would always recommend it. The recent change to packaging and product is horrible. Don't waste your money, this is nothing like the previous formula, tip or packaging (the lid comes off easily in my makeup bag). Like other loyal fans, I am so disappointed with the new version - I immediately noticed the difference in one application. You will lose a lot of fans - listen to your feedback and bring back the old version.

I have been a dedicated master precise buyer for a number of years and loved the product but this new one is beyond disappointing. It dries out too quickly, smudges too easily but won't budge with a makeup remover. Bring back the old formula, it was great! It stayed put, didn't smudge or run and was a breeze to remove when needed. I'll be on the hunt for a new eyeliner.

I loved the original Master Precise liquid eyeliner. Application was always perfect, not scratchy, didn't bleed etc. This one is rubbish. I'm so disappointed. Have hunted high and low to try to stock up on the old version but can't find it anywhere. Please save me the search for a new eyeliner and just bring back the old one that was tried and true

I have been a loyal fan and customer of the old master precise liner. Now the packaging and formula have changed and now it is the WORST liner I have ever tried to use. The tip is DRY, it doesnt come out on your lid but scrapes across your lid irritating it. The old tip was soft and inky and perfect, the new one is dry and useless. I just stocked up and bought 5 and now have to throw them all out and find a new brand. Would like a refund and explanation.

I first noticed the original Master Precise Liner fading out a couple of months ago and decided to stock up on the old formula. But now after running out of the old liners, I was forced to purchase the new one which had me hopeful because a new formula could only get better, right? But boy was I wrong... the pen tip itself had me cringing from the start. It was dry, stiff and very difficult to handle. After multiple tries, I finally got it to work the way I wanted, but couple of hours into the wear, I experienced severe smudging which made my make up look horrible. I was stuck with black rings around my eyelids the whole day as I had assumed that it wouldnt have budged.. a very disappointing outcome. Maybelline, I really hope you fix this soon, because the way I've heard other people talk about this liner is doing you no favours.

This WAS the perfect eyeliner, but you have ruined it. This redesign of the master precise is horrible. It's not precise, the tip is dry and doesn't create a sharp line or wing, it's not easy to use AT ALL. And the formulaaa whhhhyyyyyyy did you change it? It smudges in the corner of your eye over the day or if it gets bumped and is SO hard to remove! This new product is the absolutely worst. Lost a customer. Not interested in using the other eyeliner products otherwise I would have already been using them. Please put this product in the bin where it belongs and bring back the best eyeliner on the market!