I guess I would give this item 2 1/2 stars. Here's the problem: I watched a few videos about the Mer-Maid Drain stopper before deciding to buy it. I looked online to see where I could buy it, and found it here. I ordered it, expecting to get what you see in the image: the stopper, and 3 washers to choose from. The videos I watched (including the same packaging) included the 3 washers, and also there was a little Mermaid etching in the stopper itself. What I received, however, was a little tiny box with no writing on it, the stopper (without a Mermaid etched onto it), and 1 washer. In other words, Walmart advertised "As Seen On TV", but sent me a knock off. I guess it basically works. I''m giving this a low rating because I want buyers to beware that you may not get the "As Seen on TV" product. Nor, the product that is supposed to be from this Mer-Maid company. I think it's really awful that a corporation as huge as Walmart engages in false advertising and lies to its potential customers. I asked for a refund in the chat feature because of the false advertising and not receiving what is shown in the image. I would have had to return it for a refund - but I had already tried it out in my sink. My rating it based on Walmart's ethics, or lack thereof. As far as the product itself, I haven't had it long enough to know whether or not I like it. I do lift it out to let the sink drain a bit faster (especially after brushing my teeth when there are more suds). Anyway, if you buy this don't expect the brand name. Expect only 1 washer, and that if it's Walmart's error they will require you to take your time and effort to correct their mistake (or lie). I know it's not an expensive item, but to me it's about the principle of the matter.