Physicians Formula Butter Blowout Mascara, Black

Love this stuff

I used this mascara first time 3 days ago and absolutely love it. I don't need a magnifying mirror to apply. It goes onto my lashes and not all over my eyelids. The brush is like a comb and the liquid that comes out isn't drippy or splotchy at all. It simply separates my lashes beautifully, applies an even amount of mascara on each lash, and leaves no clumps. ALSO, and I can't believe this with the word BUTTER in the name—it stays on all day without smearing! I often prefer waterproof as mascara tends to smear on me. But this does not smear at all. Seeing as I've only used it 3 times, my only concern is that it will dry out quickly or there is very little in the bottle. I only say this because very little comes out onto the brush. But it could be that they finally engineered the perfect little applicator and tube that puts only the perfect amount on the applicator each time, and that's why no splotching.

I had one spot this for myself and noticed how easy it was to clean off. I bought it for my granddaughter. She loves it, my daughter approves and everybody's happy.

I really like this mascara. I know some of the reviews say that it's dry, or clumpy, I personally haven't had this issue. I don't wear very thick, dramatic mascara, so this works perfectly for me. I do have to move the brush up and down inside the tube before taking the brush out, I feel that this helps with the “clumps”. The smell of this product is very nice, and it does not irritate my sensitive eyes. I would absolutely buy this again, and probably will! I also use a clear serum before applying this mascara, so that may make a difference also.

The brush is a little big, There is something in the ingredients causing a sensitivity to my eyes. I am a contact lens wearer and it seemed to bother me a little more than other mascaras . As far as the appearance, it's really thick.

2 years ago, this used to smell really good and tropical. I wonder if they changed the formula. It has no scent now. It doesn't go on very thick or dark

Physicians Formula use to be a quality product. Not anymore. This is dry/clumpy and does not apply well at all. Suppose to be moist as they advertise it. Also discovered in very tiny writing on the box that it is make in Mexico. Oh Physicians Formula you should be ashamed. Quality is down but the price sure is not!!

This mascara smells great and the bottle is pretty, but I make a mess almost every time I try to use it. It leaves clumps. I try to fix it and end up making it worse. I wanted to switch to Physicians Formula for all of my makeup, but I'm afraid to try another one of their mascaras.

This came out of the package very clumpy and so was clumping on lashes. Would not recommend.

Seems like it's old and dried up. Couldn't even get enough for one use.