Reese's Creamy Peanut Butter Spread, Jar 18 oz price history and forecast - Reese's 40012
Reese's Creamy Peanut Butter Spread, Jar 18 oz

Reese's Creamy Peanut Butter Spread, Jar 18 oz

Brand:
Reese's
Model Number:
40012
UPC:
034000400126
EAN:
0034000400126
Walmart SKU:
10312039
Key Takeaway

Trending downward with a $0.00 move to reach $3.92. Current price runs 0.0% below the 90-day average.

Third-Party Seller Summary

Third-Party Seller Price History Summary
Price Type Price Date
Highest Price
$14.22
Lowest Price
$3.12
Most Recent Price
$11.73
Average Price
$7.32
First Tracked
Last Update

Walmart.com Summary

Walmart.com Price History Summary
Price Type Price Date
Highest Price
$3.92
Lowest Price
$3.38
Most Recent Price
$3.92
Average Price
$3.58
First Tracked
Last Update

Price Analysis

Tracking History: We have tracked Reese's Creamy Peanut Butter Spread, Jar 18 oz since 10/26/2022. The most recent price update was on Oct 9, 2026.

Price Range: Over the past 90 days, the price has ranged from $3.38 (lowest on 10/26/2022) to $3.92 (highest on 3/30/2026). The average price during this period is $3.58.

Current Trend: Walmart.com prices have ranged from $3.92 (Oct 9) to $3.92 (Oct 9) over the past 90 days. Current price is close to the 90-day average of $3.92.

Customer Insights: Rated 4.6/5 from 2053 reviews.

Customer Reviews

2053 reviews

Customer Reviews

4.6
Based on 2053 reviews
5
1691
4
136
3
81
2
44
1
101
Filter Reviews:
Sort By:
Showing 10 of 2053 reviews

Tasty

Marilyn December 13, 2025

The Reese's Peanut Butter Spread is really tasty. The texture is smooth and creamy. It is great on granola bars (my favorite) and in peanut butter and jelly sandwiches too. I really love the taste of this peanut butter.

Was this review helpful?

Can't Go Wrong With The Nostalgic Orange!

anonymous July 3, 2026

We will always buy the GV peanut butter, but we had to give the Reese's peanut butter a try. I'm glad we did. My family likes peanut butter filled pretzel bites, but you don't get many for the price. So, we bought a jar of the Reese's peanut butter and a bag of pretzel rods, and I had a family full of happy campers! The flavor just tastes so Retro. Being in my 50s, we grew up eating peanut butter cups. Just about every house gave Reese's peanut butter cups out at Halloween. Not only the flavor, but the Nostalgic "orange wrapper", just makes the experience that much better. If nothing else, just give it a try to say you did, but if you buy it again and again, I'll simply say, "I told you so!" lol

Was this review helpful?

Read ingredients - Plus Sugar

cindy January 21, 2026

It’s just peanut butter with added sugar. It is NOT the same texture as the Reese’s PB Cup. Save yourself some money and get a 2lb jar of Great Value %26 add honey if you want sweet PB for less. All ingredients are the same as Great Value Peanut Butter. Minus the sugar! Minus a lb.

Was this review helpful?

just regular peanut butter

Torch June 18, 2026

If you're buying this thinking it will taste like eating the peanut butter from a Reese's cup, it doesn't. It just taste like regular creamy peanut butter. It is very smooth though and easy to spread but I was just disappointed with how it tasted just like any other creamy peanut butter. I won't get it again.

Was this review helpful?

Reeces pea not…

Alicia July 16, 2026

The company decided to hollow out the bottom of the jar. Then it went up a dollar. It does not last as long maybe less than a week. I cook a bunch with Reeces, i make pB toast, in greek yogurt, cookies, pies, cheesecake. But Im going to change brands I was deceived its engineered food. That sucks.

Was this review helpful?

No reese's flavor profile

Linear February 13, 2026

It's good but tastes like regular creamy p.b. I don't get the Reese's taste from it. Would I buy it again? No. I will continue to buy natural p.b. since this doesn't have the reese's flavor profile.

Was this review helpful?

Disgusting

anonymous July 24, 2026

I am so confused by the other reviews on this peanut butter. I have literally never tasted a worst peanut butter in my life. I would eat that oily natural no sweetness added stuff then this. it's horrible. Not only does it not taste anything like reeces peanut butter from their products, it doesn't taste like peanut butter. It tastes like someone tried to chemically infuse liquid plastic with peanut butter flavoring, and failed drastically. Even the texture feels like plastic in my mouth. This made me appreciate the disgusting peanut butter I got from the dollar store one time. Do not buy this crap.

Was this review helpful?
Mister January 5, 2026

it says on the apps picture that it's an 18 Oz jar of peanut butter. I ordered two of them and I got two 2 oz jars of peanut butter. I'm not satisfied at all and I'm trying to figure out a way to get a hold of Walmart to let him know that I got the wrong item.

Was this review helpful?

I used to Love this brand

Scott August 22, 2026

I used to love this peanut butter spread but lately it's just not the same. The taste is bitter and the spread is not creamy, but inconsistently stiff and if you dare put it in the fridge it becomes like cement. I contacted them a few months back and they blew of the inconsistent spread that was bitter as "not being mixed enough" and she assured me she would pass my email on to manufacturing. It doesn't seem like they care enough to fix the problem because this last jar I bought has the same issues. I actually stopped buying this brand for a while and then hoping the issues were fixed I came back. This will be my last purchase of this brand.

Was this review helpful?
BARB September 19, 2026

Never received the item. Its wrong that customers can't get a refund before 2 days and drivers can state it was delivered and it wasn't and that is ok with Walmart

Was this review helpful?

Price History

Historical price data graph for Reese's Creamy Peanut Butter Spread, Jar 18 oz

Recent Price Changes

Detailed price history for the past 90 days

Walmart.com Pricing

2 records

Walmart.com prices have ranged from $3.92 (Oct 9) to $3.92 (Oct 9) over the past 90 days. Current price is close to the 90-day average of $3.92.

Walmart.com price history for Reese's Creamy Peanut Butter Spread, Jar 18 oz showing recent price changes over the past 90 days
Date Price Change % Change
$3.92 $+0.00 +0.0%
$3.92 — —

Third-Party Seller Pricing

75 records

Third-Party Sellers prices have ranged from $3.77 (Sep 14) to $12.61 (Oct 7) over the past 90 days. Current price is 52.8% above the 90-day average of $7.68.

Third-party seller price history for Reese's Creamy Peanut Butter Spread, Jar 18 oz showing recent price changes
Date Price Change % Change
$11.73 $+0.00 +0.0%
$11.73 $+0.00 +0.0%
$11.73 $+5.74 +95.8%
$5.99 $-6.59 -52.4%
$12.58 $+6.59 +110.0%
$5.99 $-6.59 -52.4%
$12.58 $+6.59 +110.0%
$5.99 $+0.00 +0.0%
$5.99 $-6.59 -52.4%
$12.58 $+6.59 +110.0%
$5.99 $+0.00 +0.0%
$5.99 $+1.00 +20.0%
$4.99 $+0.00 +0.0%
$4.99 $+0.00 +0.0%
$4.99 $+0.00 +0.0%
$4.99 $+0.00 +0.0%
$4.99 $+0.00 +0.0%
$4.99 $+0.00 +0.0%
$4.99 $+0.00 +0.0%
$4.99 $+0.00 +0.0%
$4.99 $-7.62 -60.4%
$12.61 $+7.62 +152.7%
$4.99 $-7.62 -60.4%
$12.61 $+7.62 +152.7%
$4.99 $+0.00 +0.0%
$4.99 $-7.62 -60.4%
$12.61 $+7.62 +152.7%
$4.99 $+0.00 +0.0%
$4.99 $+0.00 +0.0%
$4.99 $-7.62 -60.4%
$12.61 $+7.62 +152.7%
$4.99 $-4.99 -50.0%
$9.98 $+0.00 +0.0%
$9.98 $+0.00 +0.0%
$9.98 $+4.99 +100.0%
$4.99 $-7.62 -60.4%
$12.61 $+7.62 +152.7%
$4.99 $+0.00 +0.0%
$4.99 $-7.62 -60.4%
$12.61 $+7.62 +152.7%
$4.99 $+1.22 +32.4%
$3.77 $+0.00 +0.0%
$3.77 $-1.02 -21.3%
$4.79 $+0.00 +0.0%
$4.79 $+0.00 +0.0%
$4.79 $-0.20 -4.0%
$4.99 $-6.34 -56.0%
$11.33 $+0.00 +0.0%
$11.33 $-0.16 -1.4%
$11.49 $+0.00 +0.0%
$11.49 $+6.50 +130.3%
$4.99 $-6.34 -56.0%
$11.33 $+6.34 +127.1%
$4.99 $-6.34 -56.0%
$11.33 $+0.11 +1.0%
$11.22 $+0.00 +0.0%
$11.22 $-0.17 -1.5%
$11.39 $+0.17 +1.5%
$11.22 $+0.00 +0.0%
$11.22 $+0.00 +0.0%
$11.22 $+0.00 +0.0%
$11.22 $+0.00 +0.0%
$11.22 $+6.23 +124.8%
$4.99 $+0.00 +0.0%
$4.99 $+0.00 +0.0%
$4.99 $+0.00 +0.0%
$4.99 $+0.00 +0.0%
$4.99 $+0.00 +0.0%
$4.99 $+0.00 +0.0%
$4.99 $+0.00 +0.0%
$4.99 $+0.00 +0.0%
$4.99 $+0.00 +0.0%
$4.99 $+0.00 +0.0%
$4.99 $-6.51 -56.6%
$11.50 — —

Related Products