Reese's Creamy Peanut Butter Spread, Jar 18 oz price history and forecast - Reese's 40012
Reese's Creamy Peanut Butter Spread, Jar 18 oz

Reese's Creamy Peanut Butter Spread, Jar 18 oz

Brand:
Reese's
Model Number:
40012
UPC:
034000400126
EAN:
0034000400126
Walmart SKU:
10312039
Key Takeaway

Trending downward with a $0.00 move to reach $3.92. Current price runs 0.0% below the 90-day average.

Third-Party Seller Summary

Third-Party Seller Price History Summary
Price Type Price Date
Highest Price
$14.22
Lowest Price
$3.12
Most Recent Price
$11.50
Average Price
$7.51
First Tracked
Last Update

Walmart.com Summary

Walmart.com Price History Summary
Price Type Price Date
Highest Price
$3.92
Lowest Price
$3.38
Most Recent Price
$3.92
Average Price
$3.51
First Tracked
Last Update

Price Analysis

Tracking History: We have tracked Reese's Creamy Peanut Butter Spread, Jar 18 oz since 10/26/2022. The most recent price update was on Apr 19, 2026.

Price Range: Over the past 90 days, the price has ranged from $3.38 (lowest on 10/26/2022) to $3.92 (highest on 3/30/2026). The average price during this period is $3.51.

Current Trend: Walmart.com prices have ranged from $3.92 (Apr 19) to $3.92 (Apr 19) over the past 90 days. Current price is close to the 90-day average of $3.92.

Customer Insights: Rated 4.5/5 from 1475 reviews.

Customer Reviews

1475 reviews

Customer Reviews

4.5
Based on 1475 reviews
5
1179
4
103
3
68
2
37
1
88
Filter Reviews:
Sort By:
Showing 10 of 1475 reviews

Dessert in a Jar—Peanut Butter Perfection

Julie June 11, 2025

If you love Reese’s, this spread is a no-brainer. It’s like someone scooped the inside of a peanut butter cup into a jar—smooth, creamy, and just the right balance of sweet and salty. I’ve used it on toast, in smoothies, and straight off the spoon (no shame), and it never disappoints. The texture is silky without being oily, and it spreads easily without tearing up your bread. It’s also a fun twist for baking—try it in cookies or swirled into brownies for a rich, nutty upgrade. Bonus: the twist-top lid keeps it fresh, and the jar lasts a while even with regular snacking. If you’re a peanut butter fan with a sweet tooth, this one hits the mark.

Was this review helpful?

Sooo Good!

Steve May 20, 2026

We bought Jiff for 35 years or more and loved it. My Mom always bought it. We also Loved the organic or whatever it's called. Then there was a recall or something several years ago and our friend picked up our groceries and bought Reese's. I actually felt very bad for the Jiff people, even guilty because we'd bought it so long, as stupid as tgat sounds, but we simply liked this better. It's a bit higher but I think it's worth the difference. As for value for the money, I suppose it is a good buy if it's what you like, however,there are limits.

Was this review helpful?

Great for baking

SunShine4me40 November 9, 2025

The is the best peanut butter for baking especially if you are making peanut butter balls. It never leaves my batter sticky or has oily taste that other peanut butter has in them.

Was this review helpful?

Tsdty Treat

Josephine December 17, 2025

My husband and I both LOVE the rich and smooth texture of Reese's as evening snack...we like to spread peanut butter across a banana and find this to be a tasty and fast treat.

Was this review helpful?

Tasty

Marilyn December 13, 2025

The Reese’s Peanut Butter Spread is really tasty. The texture is smooth and creamy. It is great on granola bars (my favorite) and in peanut butter and jelly sandwiches too. I really love the taste of this peanut butter.

Was this review helpful?

Read ingredients - Plus Sugar

cindy January 21, 2026

It’s just peanut butter with added sugar. It is NOT the same texture as the Reese’s PB Cup. Save yourself some money and get a 2lb jar of Great Value %26 add honey if you want sweet PB for less. All ingredients are the same as Great Value Peanut Butter. Minus the sugar! Minus a lb.

Was this review helpful?

No reese's flavor profile

Linear February 13, 2026

It's good but tastes like regular creamy p.b. I don't get the Reese's taste from it. Would I buy it again? No. I will continue to buy natural p.b. since this doesn't have the reese's flavor profile.

Was this review helpful?
Mister January 5, 2026

it says on the apps picture that it's an 18 Oz jar of peanut butter. I ordered two of them and I got two 2 oz jars of peanut butter. I'm not satisfied at all and I'm trying to figure out a way to get a hold of Walmart to let him know that I got the wrong item.

Was this review helpful?

Tastes like normal peanut butter

Gabrielle August 14, 2025

I was so excited to try this product since I love Reese's so much but was extremely disappointed when I got it. It tastes nothing like Reese's peanut butter but rather a normal peanut butter. Don't spend extra for this expensive peanut butter. If you want Reese's buy Reese's but if you want peanut butter save your money and buy the off brand. There isn't a difference in taste.

Was this review helpful?
brandi August 20, 2025

I thought this would remind me of the flavor and texture of the peanut butter in the cups. It tastes the same as great value but watered down with veg oil. Half the size for twice the price. dont waste your money like i did thinking this would be better. this is the worst peanut butter ive ever had.

Was this review helpful?

Price History

Historical price data graph for Reese's Creamy Peanut Butter Spread, Jar 18 oz

Recent Price Changes

Detailed price history for the past 90 days

Walmart.com Pricing

2 records

Walmart.com prices have ranged from $3.92 (Apr 19) to $3.92 (Apr 19) over the past 90 days. Current price is close to the 90-day average of $3.92.

Walmart.com price history for Reese's Creamy Peanut Butter Spread, Jar 18 oz showing recent price changes over the past 90 days
Date Price Change % Change
$3.92 $+0.00 +0.0%
$3.92

Third-Party Seller Pricing

30 records

Third-Party Sellers prices have ranged from $3.67 (Apr 14) to $11.50 (Jun 5) over the past 90 days. Current price is 54.9% above the 90-day average of $7.42.

Third-party seller price history for Reese's Creamy Peanut Butter Spread, Jar 18 oz showing recent price changes
Date Price Change % Change
$11.50 $+6.51 +130.5%
$4.99 $-6.51 -56.6%
$11.50 $+1.10 +10.6%
$10.40 $+6.05 +139.1%
$4.35 $-4.15 -48.8%
$8.50 $+0.00 +0.0%
$8.50 $+0.00 +0.0%
$8.50 $+4.60 +117.9%
$3.90 $-5.89 -60.2%
$9.79 $-0.21 -2.1%
$10.00 $+0.60 +6.4%
$9.40 $+0.00 +0.0%
$9.40 $+0.00 +0.0%
$9.40 $-0.10 -1.1%
$9.50 $+4.51 +90.4%
$4.99 $+0.64 +14.7%
$4.35 $+0.68 +18.5%
$3.67 $-0.63 -14.7%
$4.30 $-5.70 -57.0%
$10.00 $+0.00 +0.0%
$10.00 $+5.70 +132.6%
$4.30 $-5.70 -57.0%
$10.00 $+0.00 +0.0%
$10.00 $+5.70 +132.6%
$4.30 $+0.00 +0.0%
$4.30 $-5.70 -57.0%
$10.00 $+5.70 +132.6%
$4.30 $+0.00 +0.0%
$4.30 $+0.00 +0.0%
$4.30

Related Products