Wet n Wild H2O Proof Liquid Eyeliner - Dark Brown

I love this product!!!! I have oily skin and my eyeliner never lasts past a few hours but this lasts all day! I have tried other eyeliner like k- pallet, younique , rimmel London liquid liner and they just don't last. It does smear a little but I have to use an oil based makeup remover to remove it.

I love it waterproof, it doesn't smudge, I take it off with cream the only thing I don't like is the brush is to hard and not a good one to apply but other than that I LOVE IT. specially the price

it is definitely waterproof and a great product. if I don't wash my face it would literally stay on for a couple days before you'll see it to fade. you will definitely need makeup remover.

The application wand is extremely stiff and it actually hurts and scrapes your eye lid as you try to apply,it does not go on easy,as It should flow ,it's almost impossible to make a straight even line due to the stiff wand it won't glide . I can't even use it , I have set it aside to go in the trash.

Hmmm, where do I begin ….eyeliner hard to remove w waterproof eye makeup removers …also w eyelash glue it on and very hard to remove (when wearing false lashes)…. but when worn alone on lid above natural lashes it falls off in little specks when it's dried and worn during the day on my lids , ….very wet runny consistency when applying , love wet n wild , and do recommend , just this eyeliner , mabe there's some trick to applying %26 removing it that I just don't know about, I'm glad it works for some other people , wanted it to work for me….also I don't get sensitivity with it on …but…lids end up sensitive after gently rubbing trying to removie it ….it'd be great for me if I could just buy a set that has both : waterproof eyeliner %26 it's waterproof eye makeup remover bigger bottle , that would make it more fool proof for me to remove

There was no brush on the liquid eyeliner applicator, just a hard, angled plastic tip. I'm not sure if this was a defective bottle, or an unwelcome design, but it's unusable.

first use, tip is weird. like it's trying to be a felt tip but it's hard and long, like it night be a brush that was super old. i seriously couldn't tell and it was so hard and scratchy it was hard to work with. i use bith brushes and felt so.... this made the application tricky to work with but I still would gave used it but this stuff isn't even air proof, much less water proof. i don't make it 10 minutes outside without streaks and that's with plenty of prep and primers.

This is an item I always order from walmart. Never had any issues, but this time it came all crusted up and the eyeliner had white gunk all in the inside. Disappointed!

Horrible not water proof. I had raccoons and mascara smear on my eye lids as well. Hard to remove the raccoon eyes was a big old mess. Bad all the way around.

This is so NOT waterproof. Terrible eyeliner. ive had it on for less than an hour only on my top lid and i already look like a racoon. This is very messy. it would be bad enough as a regular eyeliner but to market this as "H2O proof" is absolutely deceitful. ive been trying to wipe off the smudge all day, then i washed it off when i got home, then still put on makeup remover before AND after i washed and its still lingering. TERRIBLE!!