Milani The Waterproof One Mascara

I was skeptical …expecting it to not last and leave streaks from my eyes watering due to dry air. I was pleasantly surprised that it went on with good coverage and no clumping and lasted the entire day.

Waterproof is what I'm wearing when going to parties or events and it's just the best thing to have

I'm extremely pleased with this product! It does what it's supposed to: lengthens, thickens, lift and is water-proof! It even survived a day at a theme park with water rides! I'm blessed with naturally long, curly, dark lashes, and this stuff makes them look as good as falsie! Hypo-allergenic, water-proof mascara is a must because I wear contacts and don't want it fading under my eyes. I was using another, more expensive water-proof brand, but when they stopped making it, I turned to this one and will never go back. I hope they never stop making it! I have used other Milani products for the same reason: they are cruelty-free, high-quality, wok well, and are more affordable than comparable products in other brands.

I normally like this brand, blush, eyeshadows have all been great! So that's why I picked the mascara to try, but I wasn't a fan because it's not very waterproof. With a summer's day I looked scary with my mascara all under my eyes.

This mascara is very thick, too thick to allow lash separation. Also, it's all settled on my lower eyelids within a few hours, giving a “raccoon” effect. Don't waste your money.

Not my favorite, made my lashes feel heavy and seemed to never dry completely

Worst mascara, one it's not waterproof, it flakes off, Andis not worth a darn for anything except writing on paper. It's that bad

It is impossible to remove . I used makeup remover, soap, %26 shampoo. Horrible! Smudges under eyes during day. Junk!

I really wanted to like this one because my lashes look so pretty, but then after a few hours, it melts off underneath my eyes! I tried it 3 times and it did it every time. I've never had a mascara so this. Definitely not waterproof!

I have worn this mascara twice now and both times I hated it. It's labelled as waterproof, but in about an hour you'll look like a racoon with black circles under your eyes even though i didnt even cry or sweat. The worst part about it is I have washed my face three times trying to get it off. Ive used makeup remover, face wash, and eye cream to try to take it off. Today, the day after i wore it, it's still leaving a lighter tinge of black under my lashes somehow and i have literally washed my face three times trying to remove it and didnt wear makeup today. Its horrible