Color right, retractable color means no grinding away large parts of the liner in a pencil sharpener.. Keeping a point is still hard, even with the retractable feature, meaning that in even in this form much of what you pay for and love is lost. But the color is great, it last well, is is as creamy and spreadable as advertised, And pretty much as lasting s one could hope! use it as lid-shadow as well (finger-work helps keep the point sharp) and order these 5 at a time to use the free shipping --meaning I get almost another pencll ffor what I would be spending for shipping. I plan to use this as long as it is available. Oh, and the 4 rating is because it will not --probaby cannot--keep a point.--but better than most!