Pennington Select Thistle Seed, Dry Wild Bird Feed and Seed, 5 lb. Bag, 1 Pack

Every bird that comes to my feeders loves thistle. The only other food we buy is suet for the woodpeckers and hummer food . The gold finches, chickadees and others are at our thistle feeders every day , crowding the perches! Even our pet finch loves it.

Every year I'd have a handful of Goldfinch sightings at my house. It was only in spring. I thought they migrated through but NOPE! they were waiting for me to put this feeder

I've looked everywhere and Walmart has the best price for this expensive seed. We have over 100 finches visiting every day now and they can't get enough of this. All you need are some finch seed bags and you're all set.

I have to fill my thistle feeder socks every few days. They really like this seed. It must be really fresh or something.

As good as it gets. Premium low waste seed at a better price. May have to go to a 20# bag to save more as the three sacks I have have about 20 Gold Finches & 10 red House Finches daily.....getting crowded....

Good price and the finches come back over and over.

Bag cam opened and when I took it out of the Walmart bag, the seed all fell into the clay wet soaking icky mud by the bird feeder. The bag came ripped and it was in the bottom of the bag. When I took it out of the Walmart tang it all fell into the mud. Returning empty bag??

Birds love it.

They love it! We have lots of finches visiting. Within minutes of refilling a thistle seed sock, they are lined up waiting for a turn to eat. The only problem is I have to buy the seed more often now 😂

Seed dried out. Not good.found tiny tiny hole in bag. The oil in thistle attracts birds. This is dried out. No oil. Audubon said do crush test. Crush in paper towel. If no oils spot, seed is no good. This bag did not pass test. Am requesting replacement or refund.