e.l.f. Lash XTNDR Mascara, Pitch Black

I bought this to try a “tubing” mascara, which is basically a lengthening mascara, as far as I could figure out. Ordered it in black, which was not available so I accepted the deep brown color. Not much difference in color. This is a decent mascara. Easy to apply, and does not clump on lashes. It lasted all day, with no smearing, smudging, or flaking. The applicator bristle brush is a good size, and holds just the right amount of product. The lengthening effect is especially noticeable on lower lashes. Easily washes off. I really like E.L.F. products, and would buy this again. They are good quality and not too pricey.

This is the best mascara! It separates your lashes and lifts them for a natural appearance. The best part is how it comes off! It just slides off your lashes, no smearing you into a raccoon! I’ve been in the pool with it on and I just slide it off my lashes with my fingers, easy peasy! The lid did give out quickly and it didn’t close very tightly.

I love this stuff! It doesn’t flake or smear even after blowing rain. I’ve slept in it and woke up with lashes looking just as good as the day before – not all bent and clumped. Again, I love it!

i absolutely love this product, firstly i have to admit im not an Elf product purchaseer however this product stuns . goes on very well and appears to build lashes. i have very tint almost obsolete lashs but one swipe with this wand and ot was like i was wearing falsies. absolutely amazing product

I absolutely love this mascara! It’s easy to apply and take off, and it leaves your eyelashes so luxurious! The color is nice, and a tube lasts me about 1.5 months after using it daily. I highly recommend if you love long lashes!

I have used another tubing mascara for a few years now. I wanted to try this because I heard good things. I'm glad I did. I will be buying this mascara from now on. The formula is very similar and costs much less. Also I didn't get flakes with this mascara like I often do with the other mascara.

I have short, stubby, blonde lashes. This mascara is very good at thickening and lengthening my lashes. I actually have nice lashes when applying this mascara. It does take a bit of "sculpting" to keep the lashes separate and not to clump terribly. This lash Extender really does make my lashes appear longer. The brush is firm and straight. Mascara is very durable, does not run or smudge. Removal takes a bit of effort; I have to use cold cream or makeup remover. Yes, it is a good product. I will purchase it again.

I like this mascara BUT it doesn’t last long before drying out to the point it’s too clumpy to use. It washes off easily which I like, and doesn’t smudge while wearing. Stays on all day. Because the tube dries out it just doesn’t last as long as others so I did switch brands.

Bought this as a dupe for my favorite Thrive Tubing Mascara. It works decently well. I still think the Thrive brand is a bit better, but this is super comparable to save some money! Love the tubing ability and that it helps my thin lashes look longer! Only reason I have it a 3 was for 2 reasons. 1. I do need more coats of the mascara to get the full look I want. 2. After a few months after use, the part that takes off the excessive product broke. So I still have lots of product in the mascara tube, but can't use it anymore since it broke. That's a big bummer.

I have used the elf Lash and Roll mascara and quite like it. I thought I would try this one but I am not as impressed with it as I am the Lash and Roll. It doesn't hold the curl very well doesn't apply well when you get to the second and third coats, which are needed for any effect at all